Winter guide · Ontario

Ice dams, snow load, and snow guards in Ontario

Ice dams start in the attic, not on the panel. Warm air leaks up, melts snow on the deck, and that water freezes at a cold eave. Steel can shed the pack and it does not wick like shingle laps. It does not shut off attic heat. We put snow guards where a slide would hit a door, walkway, or valley, we keep the troughs clear for spring melt, and we do not take an axe to the ice.

How a dam forms.

How an ice dam forms — a cross-section of a typical Ontario roof in winter
How an ice dam forms — a cross-section of a typical Ontario roof in winter.

An ice dam is a ridge of ice at the eave. It starts when warm air leaks from the living space into the attic. That heat warms the roof deck. Snow sitting on a warm deck melts from below. The meltwater runs to the overhang. The overhang sits past the heated walls, so it stays cold. The water freezes there and builds a ridge. Melt then backs up behind that ridge.

That sequence does not start on the panel. Ice dams start in the attic. Air sealing, insulation, and ventilation that keep the deck cold are the lasting work.

Three problems. Do not mash them.

Backup leak

Water that cannot drain at the eave finds a path under the roofing and into the house. Asphalt shingle laps can wick. Steel does not wick the same way, and it sheds water better. That changes the leak path. It does not mean the attic heat is gone.

Sliding snow

On steel, snow slides. A slide that comes off in one sheet is a hazard at a door, a walkway, or a parked car. Snow that slides is a hazard we plan for. That is a separate problem from the backup leak.

Snow load on the structure

The roof still has to carry what sits on it. Shedding can reduce how long a pack stays on the slope. It does not let you ignore the load the structure was built to carry. We do not print a load number for a typical house. That figure belongs to the building, not to a brochure.

What a bad winter actually looks like.

The pattern goes like this. A heavy snowfall lands. Then a warm spell — Ontario can reach ten degrees in January — and it melts down and turns ice-like. Sometimes wet snow or outright rain adds to it. Then the temperature drops hard overnight and it flash freezes. Repeat that a few times and the layer builds. Customers have reported a foot of ice sitting on the roof, and it does not leave quickly: in spring it can take three weeks to melt off. That whole time it is dead weight and constant pressure, with no airflow underneath. On shingles that are already curled, cracked, or shedding their granules, meltwater finds a way through — into the plywood deck, and then into the attic or the room below it.

We were called to a roof in Angus where exactly that happened — meltwater came through and into an upstairs bedroom. On another job, the owners had gone away for the winter and came home to find the kitchen ceiling had come down, taking most of the room with it. Both became insurance claims. Whether ice damming is genuinely getting worse or the last few winters have simply been bad ones, we cannot say. It has been noticeably more common.

Check your eavestroughs for granules — free, today.

The clearest sign a roof is aging out is not on the roof — it is in the eavestrough. Asphalt shingles shed granules as they age: the fine stone that gives the shingle its surface washes into the eavestroughs, out the downspouts, and ends up on the grass below. You can check that from the ground, today, without a ladder.

Thirteen to seventeen years — a figure Colum arrived at from a decade of surveying the roofs he was tearing off, not from a manufacturer’s brochure. Treat it as a guide, not a guarantee: we have seen a subdivision roof only eight years old shedding granules heavily, so the granules are the actual signal and the years are context.

Worth checking too: valleys, wall flashings, and chimney areas, where water concentrates, plus any shingles lifted or blown loose after a storm.

Anywhere around the fifteen-year mark, thirteen to seventeen years, that’s when you really want to start taking a look.

What steel changes — and what it does not.

Steel changes the leak path and can shed the pack. It does not shut off attic heat. Ice dams start in the attic. A Heritage Series standing-seam roof sheds the same way. It still does not replace air sealing.

In The Blue Mountains the freeze-thaw is harder, and the same attic-first rule holds. A metal roof does not replace that work.

In Angus, Essa Township, homeowners come to us after a winter of ice and water. See the Wakefield Bridge roof in Angus, Essa.

We are roofers, not the insulation contractor. We will tell you if the attic needs a look.

Steel sheds snow. Snow guards decide when and where.

Worth being straight about it: snow and ice on a metal roof do not behave the way they do on asphalt. A shingle surface is rough and grips the snow, holding it where it lands. Steel is smooth and sheds — which is most of the point of it — and that means a load can release in one go rather than sitting there melting quietly away. That is a genuine drawback of a metal roof, not a footnote. It is also entirely manageable, and the way you manage it is snow guards.

A snow guard holds snow on the roof. That is the point of it.

Most people assume a snow guard helps snow come off faster. It does the opposite, deliberately. Snow guards hold the pack in place so it melts down gradually and runs into the gutters over days, rather than letting go all at once. You are trading a sudden slide for a slow melt — and above a door, a walkway or a parked car, the slow melt is what you want.

Where they go

This is a conversation to have with your roofer before the roof goes on, not after the first slide. The places worth planning for:

Any entrance or doorway. A back deck or barbecue area. A hot tub. Over the garage door and the driveway — so you are not shovelling a foot of snow that just came off the roof and landed in front of the car. Paths and walkways you actually use in winter. And anywhere pets go out in the winter months.

How many, and exactly where, comes down to the geometry of your roof — which slopes shed onto what. That is a site-visit question, not something to work out from a drawing.

Two things decide whether a snow guard is any good

Neither is the shape of it, which is the part people look at. There is a simpler way to think about both: a snow guard should be built to the same specification as the roof it is bolted to. On a Wakefield Bridge roof that means two things.

Galvalume, not plastic. The shingle itself is Galvalume — a zinc-and-aluminium coating over steel — and the guard should be the same. Plastic goes brittle under years of sun, and a heavy release, a foot or two of snow letting go at once, can crack one and carry it off the roof along with the snow. A snow guard has to hold a load in year twenty-five as reliably as it did in year one.

A Kynar 500 coating. This is the one almost nobody asks about, and it is where a cheap guard gives itself away. Wakefield Bridge shingles are finished in Kynar 500 resin-based PVDF paint — the top of the range for metal roofing — so a guard finished in anything less will age at a different rate to the roof around it and start to show.

Kynar’s record is unusually well documented, because the industry has been leaving samples outdoors and photographing them for decades. There is a test fence in South Florida — about the harshest ultraviolet exposure in North America — that has been running since 1967, with half of each colour chip covered so the two can be compared directly. After fifty years the exposed halves still hold their colour. A separate fence built by a Japanese steelmaker in 1981 found that after fourteen years, Kynar was the only coating on it that still looked like itself.

The usual cheaper alternatives — silicone-modified polyester and similar — have ten to fifteen years of that kind of data behind them, and they chalk and grey as they age. Because snow guards sit in rows across the most visible part of the roof, that is precisely where you would notice it. A good roof at year fifteen with a line of washed-out hardware along the eave is a self-inflicted problem, and avoiding it costs very little at the point of specification.

The guards we fit are colour-matched to the roof, so they read as part of it rather than as something added afterwards.

How they go on

On a Wakefield Bridge roof the manufacturer sets out the method, and we follow it. Guards go along the eave in two staggered rows, each one seated against a horizontal shingle joint, spaced no more than twelve inches apart. On a steep roof, or one with long rafters carrying more snow, they go closer together.

Each guard is bedded on a continuous bead of sealant, pressed down onto solid backing, and fixed with three screws through the base. Every screw carries a neoprene washer, tightened until the washer is compressed by about half — enough to seal, not so much that it is crushed. That washer is the part standing between a fixing and a leak, and it is a small component doing a disproportionate amount of the work.

None of that is difficult. It is just exacting, and it is the difference between guards that are still holding snow in twenty years and guards that come off in the first bad winter. How those details go on a roof more broadly is in our installation process.

Winter questions

What homeowners ask after a hard winter.

Does a metal roof stop ice dams?
Not on its own. An ice dam starts when warm air leaks into the attic, warms the deck, and melts the snow sitting on it. That water runs to the cold overhang and freezes. Steel sheds water better than asphalt and does not wick like shingle laps. It does not shut off attic heat. The lasting work is air sealing, insulation, and ventilation that keep the deck cold.
Does a metal roof replace attic work?
No. Ice dams start in the attic. We will tell you if the attic needs a look.
Why has there been so much ice on roofs the last few winters?
Heavy snow, then a warm spell that melts it down, then a hard overnight freeze — repeated through the winter until the layer is thick. We have seen a foot of it, and it can take three weeks to melt off in spring. It is dead weight the whole time, and on worn shingles the meltwater works through the shingle into the deck below. Worth noting that classic ice damming has a separate cause: warm air leaking from the attic melts snow from underneath. Air sealing and insulation fix that, and no roof of any material substitutes for that work.
How long should asphalt shingles last before I need to replace them?
Thirteen to seventeen years in Ontario, which is Colum's own figure from a decade of surveying the roofs he was tearing off rather than anything from a manufacturer's brochure. The earliest tell is granules — the fine stone that sheds off the shingle surface, collects in your eavestroughs, washes out the downspouts and ends up on the grass. We have seen a subdivision roof only eight years old shedding heavily, so treat the number as a guide and the granules as the actual signal.
Do I need snow guards on a metal roof?
It depends on what sits below the eaves and how the roof is shaped. If there is a door, a deck, a walkway, a driveway or a hot tub under a slope that sheds, then yes. Colum will tell you where they are needed on the site visit — it is part of the conversation rather than an add-on afterwards.
Won’t snow guards stop my roof shedding snow?
That is what they are for. They hold the snow so it melts down gradually into the gutters instead of releasing in a single slide. The roof still clears itself — it just does it over days rather than in one second, in the places where a sudden release would be a problem.
Is sliding snow really a downside of a metal roof?
Yes, and it is better to know before you buy than after. Steel sheds where asphalt grips, and that is both the advantage and the thing you have to design around. It is not a reason to avoid a metal roof; it is a reason to talk about snow guards before the roof goes on.
What snow guards do you use?
Galvalume or comparable heavy-duty metal, never plastic, with a Kynar resin coating and colour-matched to the roof. Which particular guard depends on the roof — but those specifications do not change, and they are the ones worth asking any roofer about.
Will the snow guards fade?
Not meaningfully, with a Kynar 500 coating — the same finish as the shingles themselves. Samples on a South Florida test fence running since 1967 still hold their colour after fifty years of the harshest ultraviolet on the continent. Cheaper coatings chalk and grey within fifteen, and on snow guards that shows, because they sit in rows across the most visible part of the roof.
Why does it matter what they are made of?
Because a snow guard spends its whole life holding a load. Plastic goes brittle in the sun, and a heavy release can crack one and take it off the roof with the snow. Metal does not have that problem, and a guard should still be doing its job at year twenty-five.
Can a snow guard cause a leak?
Any fixing that goes through a roof can, if it is done badly. Each guard is bedded on sealant and fixed with three screws, every one carrying a neoprene washer compressed to about half its thickness — that is what seals the penetration, and it is the manufacturer’s own specification rather than our shortcut. Done properly it is a non-issue for the life of the roof.
Talk to Colum

After a winter of ice, get the attic question answered.

No online price. Colum comes to look, then we write the quote.